Exploring Idaho's Leading Medicare Advantage Providers

Chris Antrim • January 10, 2024

Which Medicare Insurance Company Should You Choose

Today here at our agency Chris Antrim Insurance and Boise Health & Life Insurance Agency we are going to review some of the top Medicare Insurance companies.


Now these companies work across the nation and local regional areas as well. You have large networks like Blue Cross but here in Idaho it is Blue Cross of Idaho. They sell Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. 


So see below some of the top companies we use. Our agency is independent and we work with the best companies. 


Top Medicare Supplements Insurance Companies

Here are some top companies for this year 2021:


Top Local Carriers:

  • Blue Cross of Idaho - True Blue Medicare Advantage and Medigap Plans.
  • Regence Blue Shield - They offer MAPD and Supplement plans.
  • Select Health - based out of Utah but strong presence in Idaho. They offer both plans.
idaho medicare insurance


  1. CIGNA has more than 200-year in business, making it one of the oldest companies offering health insurance and related services. This global health insurance is available in all 50 states including Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Illinois, and many more. It is known for the Best In Overall Value because of its access to discounts and perks. Cigna offers multiple policies and it has three different apps in the Google Play Store and App Store.
  2. ANTHEM is one of the largest healthcare insurance in the United States. Their companies are dedicated to delivering better care to their members. As the largest insurance provider, Anthem ranks second in the country for the number of members serving 106 million people and yearly revenue. They are known for the Best For Discounts for their easy to bundle coverage and save. Anthem Blue Cross is the same company like Blue Cross and Blue Cross Shield as they formed their associations. is the top choice for people who want to manage their membership and healthcare electronically. They are known for being the Best For Online Experience because of their friendly and easy-to-use online portal.
  3. AETNA ranks as the strongest health insurance provider. The company has a good reputation, it stands out because they offer a plan with broad coverage at affordable and lower premiums. Aetna is known for its price transparency and Best Cost-Effective and it is the fifth-largest Medigap provider by direct premiums.
  4. MUTUAL OF OMAHA is a highly ranked insurance company with excellent customer satisfaction ratings and low customer complaints. They offer high-quality, in-depth information through their company website. Mutual Of Omaha ranked number 5 in Affordable Companies of 2021 and earned an A+ rating from AM Best and S&P Global. They also know their Best For Claims Experience because according to a survey 98% of claims paid out within 12 hours. But unlike other insurance companies, Mutual Of Omaha doesn’t offer too many online tools for their customers.
  5. HUMANA is a broad-based and well-being company, they have an excellent rating and received a J.D Power Associations Awards for a “Highest Members Satisfaction among Commercial Health Plans in Texas”.


Idaho Medicare Advantage Plan Types

HMOs and PPOs are the most popular Medicare Advantage plans offered in Idaho, while SNPs and regional PFFS plans are also offered in small numbers. Medicare-eligible seniors have a variety of private insurers' plans to select from, albeit the options differ by county.


  • HMOs: Generally speaking, HMOs mandate that you obtain all of your services from in-network providers:
  • A primary care physician (PCP), referrals to specialists, and prior authorizations for some prescription drugs and procedures are all required.
  • Usually, drug coverage is included. It is not possible to get stand-alone prescription coverage.
  • Remaining in the network will save you money.
  • PPOs: PPOs offer a preferred network of providers, but at an additional expense, you can select hospitals or physicians from outside the network.
  • Selecting a primary care physician or getting recommendations for specialists is not required.
  • Usually, drug coverage is included.
  • It is not possible to get stand-alone prescription coverage.
  • increased out-of-network expenses and premiums.
  • PFFS Plans: Specialist referrals and a primary care physician are not necessary under PFFS plans:
  • You can visit any Medicare-approved healthcare facility or provider who agrees to treat you and accepts the terms of the plan for payment.
  • May come with prescription coverage, or you may buy a prescription plan separately.
  • Increased expense if you select a provider who rejects the conditions of the plan.
  • SNPs: SNPs, which are limited to individuals with particular traits and illnesses, include personalized benefits catered to your unique requirements as well as care coordination:
  • You require a PCP as well as specialist referrals.
  • There is always drug coverage.
  • You can join an SNP at any moment if you meet the requirements.


Why Consider Medicare Advantage Plans

Medicare Advantage Plans have gained significant popularity among seniors seeking comprehensive healthcare coverage. These plans, also known as Medicare Part C, offer an alternative to traditional Medicare by combining hospital and medical coverage, often including additional benefits not covered by Original Medicare alone. In this article, we explore the key reasons why considering Medicare Advantage Plans may be a wise decision for those eligible for Medicare.


  1. All-in-One Coverage: One of the primary advantages of Medicare Advantage Plans is their all-encompassing coverage. Unlike Original Medicare, which consists of separate Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance), Medicare Advantage Plans often include additional benefits such as vision, dental, and prescription drug coverage. This comprehensive approach can simplify healthcare management by consolidating multiple plans into one, streamlining the administrative process for beneficiaries.
  2. Cost Savings: Medicare Advantage Plans are known for offering cost-saving opportunities. While beneficiaries are still responsible for paying their Medicare Part B premium, many Medicare Advantage Plans come with lower out-of-pocket costs, including copayments and deductibles. Some plans even feature a maximum out-of-pocket limit, providing financial protection in case of unexpected medical expenses.
  3. Prescription Drug Coverage: Original Medicare does not cover most prescription drugs, but many Medicare Advantage Plans do. The inclusion of prescription drug coverage (Medicare Part D) is a significant benefit for individuals who require medications regularly. This can lead to substantial cost savings and greater convenience, as beneficiaries can fill all their prescriptions through a single plan.
  4. Extra Benefits and Services: Medicare Advantage Plans often go beyond the basics, offering extra benefits and services not covered by Original Medicare. These may include routine vision and dental care, hearing aids, fitness programs, and even non-emergency transportation. These additional perks can enhance overall well-being and provide a more holistic approach to healthcare.
  5. Provider Networks and Coordination of Care: Medicare Advantage Plans typically operate within provider networks, encouraging coordinated care among healthcare professionals. This can result in more streamlined and integrated healthcare services, ensuring that all aspects of a patient's health are considered. Many plans also offer care coordination services to help manage chronic conditions and prevent fragmented healthcare delivery.
  6. Flexibility in Plan Options: Medicare Advantage Plans come in various types, including Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs), Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs), and Special Needs Plans (SNPs). This diversity allows beneficiaries to choose a plan that aligns with their specific healthcare needs and preferences. Some plans may even cover out-of-network services, providing added flexibility for those who value choice in their healthcare providers.


Why Choose Chris Antrim Insurance For Your Medicare Advantage Plans

In conclusion, considering Medicare Advantage Plans is a prudent decision for individuals eligible for Medicare who seek comprehensive coverage, cost savings, and additional benefits beyond what Original Medicare provides. As the healthcare landscape continues to evolve, exploring the options offered by Medicare Advantage Plans can lead to a more tailored and holistic approach to healthcare, ultimately improving the well-being of Medicare beneficiaries.


Choosing Chris Antrim Insurance for your Medicare Advantage Plans means choosing a partner dedicated to your health and peace of mind. Don't delay—take the first step toward securing the right coverage for your unique needs. Call us today and schedule a personalized consultation. Your health deserves the best, and with Chris Antrim Insurance, you're in capable hands. Make the smart choice—choose Chris Antrim Insurance for a healthier, worry-free tomorrow!

boise health insurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency September 3, 2025
Make an HSA work: plan design, tax advantages, timing contributions, and real Boise scenarios for families and small businesses.
boise vision and dental
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency September 3, 2025
Dental/vision bundles vs separate policies in Idaho—network fit, waiting periods, allowances, and real savings for Boise households.
boise health insurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency September 3, 2025
Open Enrollment in Idaho: what to gather, how to compare plans, and a Boise-ready checklist so you keep your doctors and cut total cost.
boise aca insurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 29, 2025
Avoid common ACA mistakes in Boise: wrong network, missed subsidies, drug surprises, and timing errors. A local checklist to get it right.
idaho health insurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 29, 2025
Compare QSEHRA vs ICHRA for Idaho small employers. Budgets, classes, compliance, and employee experience—pick the right model for your Boise team.
boise medicare
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 28, 2025
Idaho Medicare Part D guide: tiers, formularies, preferred pharmacies, and annual reviews. Keep costs low in Boise with a clear meds check.
boise dental insurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 28, 2025
Compare Boise dental insurance vs cash pay. Annual maximums, waiting periods, implants, ortho, and budgeting so you actually save money.
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 28, 2025
Boise freelancers & self‑employed: compare ACA, Health Share, HSA, and off‑exchange options. Keep your doctors and control 12‑month total cost.
group healthinsurance
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 28, 2025
Compare ICHRA vs traditional group health for Boise employers. Costs, admin, employee choice, and networks—see which model fits your team.
health insurance boise
By Chris Antrim, CLTC - Boise Health & Life Agency August 26, 2025
See who qualifies for Your Health Idaho subsidies, how to estimate income, and how to keep doctors while lowering ACA premiums in Boise.